Food
Food
If you purchase from any of the Amazon links below, I earn a small commission.
Food tends to be a controversial topic with cat owners - everyone has an opinion. If you post to a Maine Coon group on Facebook asking owners what the best food for a Maine Coon is, you will get a huge variety of answers, and a few arguments will probably start with people who disagree on other people's choices. I seriously considered whether or not I should even put this section out here. Just understand that ultimately, what I put here is my opinion, and everyone has to make their own decisions. All I can do is share what we use, why we made our choices, and encourage you to do your own research and make the best possible choices for your own kitty!
Wet or Dry
This is probably the only area where most people (or at least responsible breeders) will agree: wet food is better than dry food as the primary source of food for your cat. That's not to say there isn't a place for both in a cat's diet, but by far wet food is better and should make up the primary part of their diet.
Better Hydration: Cats have a low natural thirst drive and evolved to get most of their water from prey. Wet food contains up to 80% water, which helps prevent chronic dehydration.
Urinary Tract Health: High-moisture diets dilute urine and increase urination frequency, reducing the risk of painful urinary crystals, bladder stones, and blockages. This is especially important for males since they have very narrow urethras and may be unable to pass larger crystals. This can result in a need for surgery (perineal urethrostomy, or PU) to reconstruct the narrowest part of the male cat's urethra making it wider so that urine can pass. I am familiar with this procedure because this happened to my very first Maine Coon, Bullet - it was a painful (and costly) way to learn about feeding wet food as a primary source.
Weight Management: Wet food has a lower calorie density and higher protein content than dry kibble. It helps cats feel full faster, which supports healthy weight loss or maintenance.
Lower Carbohydrates: Many dry foods contain high levels of plant-based carbohydrates, while wet foods typically feature higher protein and lower carb profiles, making them helpful for managing conditions like diabetes.
Easier Chewing and High Palatability: The strong aroma and soft texture appeal to picky eaters, kittens, and senior cats or cats with missing teeth or dental disease.
There are reasons to keep some dry food in your cat's diet as well:
Dental Health Support: Dry kibble can scrape plaque and tartar off a cat's teeth as they chew, but only if they are chewing it, not if they swallow it whole! There are also better alternatives for this, like Greenies!
Compatible with Automated Feeders: If you travel frequently or have a busy work schedule, dry food can easily be dispensed using programmable automated feeders to maintain a strict feeding routine.
Ultimately, you want to find a good balance! For our cats, they get wet food several times throughout the day because we work from home and can provide multiple small feedings, then they get dry kibble before we go to bed so they can graze over night.
Raw Diets
A lot of Maine Coon breeders and owners are proponents of a raw food diet. I am not necessarily against a raw food diet, but it isn't something I'm comfortable with - the risks outweigh any perceived benefits for my cats.
Bacterial Contamination: Pathogens like Salmonella, Listeria, and E. coli are frequently found in raw meat. Studies have shown that standard freezing or freeze-drying methods do not kill these bacteria.
Public Health Risks for Humans: Cats on a raw diet shed bacteria and parasites through their saliva and feces. This creates a severe cross-contamination risk for everyone in the household, particularly young children, elderly individuals, or anyone who is immunocompromised.
Nutritional Imbalances: Many homemade raw diets are missing vital micronutrients, or they contain them in toxic excesses. For example, feeding too much raw seafood can cause a fatal thiamine deficiency. Unless formulated precisely by a board-certified veterinary nutritionist, long-term malnutrition is a high risk. This one is the biggest con for me, and it is the risk that I'm not willing to take.
Physical Intestinal Hazards: If the bones included in a raw diet are not completely and safely pulverized, whole fragments can splinter. This can result in fractured teeth, choking, internal lacerations, or severe blockages requiring emergency surgery. I recently saw a post on another breeder's Facebook page about this very thing happening to one of her kittens - the kitten had a blockage and they had to rush him to the ER. When surgery was performed, they found tiny bone fragments that had clumped up together to form a blockage. And worst of all, her kitten didn't survive.
Primary Protein Sources
Cats are obligate carnivores, meaning their bodies are biologically designed to process nutrients from animal tissue rather than plants. They require specific amino acids like taurine and arginine, which are only found in sufficient quantities in animal proteins.
Poultry (Chicken & Turkey): these are the most common primary protein ingredient found in commercial cat foods.
Pros: Highly digestible, lean, and naturally rich in essential amino acids like taurine. It mimics a cat's ancestral diet (birds and small rodents) and is generally highly palatable.
Cons: Because it is used so widely across the pet food industry, chicken in particular is one of the most common triggers for feline food allergies.
Fish (Salmon, Tuna, & Whitefish): Fish is highly favored by many manufacturers due to its intense aroma, which appeals greatly to picky eaters.
Pros: Packed with Omega-3 fatty acids (EPA and DHA), which support joint health, cognitive function, and a shiny coat.
Cons: Fish can be addictive to cats, making them refuse other proteins. Large predatory fish (like tuna) can carry risks of heavy metal or mercury accumulation over time. Additionally, fish is another frequent allergen for cats.
Red Meat (Beef): Red meats offer an alternative flavor profile and are a robust source of iron and minerals.
Pros: Highly flavorful and calorie-dense, making it excellent for active cats or those needing to gain weight.
Cons: Beef is a top three food allergen for felines. Lower-quality beef formulations can sometimes be higher in saturated fats than poultry.
Novel Proteins (Rabbit, Duck, Venison & Quail): These are uncommon proteins that are most commonly used in elimination diets for cats being treated for food allergies.
Kitten Food
For our kittens, we start them on Fancy Feast and we mostly focus on Turkey as our protein source. You can use the variety pack as well, but I've had just enough cats with food sensitivities that I shy away from chicken as my primary protein source, and white fish is more prone to carry heavy metals or toxins. I do give our older kittens salmon twice a week.
If you have a kitten with a sensitive digestive system and/or a protein sensitivity, finding quality wet food with a novel source is not easy! We know because Kit had surgery for intussusception at only 4 months old and ever since then we've been trying to find a food that is easy on his system.
Chicken is no good for him, even the prescription diets that had chicken were awful. The Fancy Feast turkey was better, but still not quite right for him. We realized pretty quickly that we needed a food with a novel protein source, but finding one that is also formulated for a growing kitten has been challenging. Currently, we are starting him on Nulo Turkey and Duck.
For dry food, our kittens get Purina Pro Plan Kitten, Salmon.
For Kit, who needs a novel protein source, he gets Nulo FreeStyle Turkey and Duck
Adult Food
For their wet food, our adults get Purina One Grain Free - turkey as the primary protein source.
For their dry food, my adult cats get Purina Pro Plan Sensitive Skin & Stomach, Salmon & Rice
Peridia and our little domestic short hair non-Maine Coon (Kitty Despereaux) both have food sensitivities.
For their wet food, since it is their primary food source, they get a novel protein: duck.
For their dry food, they get a limited ingredient food with Turkey as the main protein.